5 February 2024 Leave a comment Tool comparisons
In the evolving landscape of mobile and web application testing, choosing the right automation tool is crucial. Testsigma offers a low-code, AI-powered test automation platform that emphasizes ease of use and is tailored for testing web, Android, and iOS applications.
It boasts a codeless approach, AI-driven features, and robust integration capabilities. On the other hand, Detox is an open-source gray box E2E testing framework, requiring coding expertise but excelling in reducing flakiness for React Native mobile apps on Android and iOS. Both tools serve distinct needs: Testsigma for its no-code convenience and Detox for its technical precision in mobile app testing.
Latest update: 1/31/2024, 5:18:29 PM
We do not guarantee the accuracy, reliability, or completeness of the information presented on our website. This includes prices, product specifications, and availability, which are subject to change. The reviews on this site are collected from g2.com and crozdesk.com and summarized by us.
Feature comparison of Testsigma and Detox
| Feature | Testsigma | Detox |
|---|---|---|
| Free Plan | ✔ | ✔ |
| On Premise | ✔ | ✔ |
| Device Farm | ✔ | – |
| Scheduler | ✔ | – |
| Test Recorder | ✔ | N/A |
| Physical Device Testing | ✔ | N/A |
| No Code | ✔ | – |
| Uses Ai | ✔ | – |
| Generates Reports | ✔ | – |
| Uses Computer Vision | N/A | – |
| Platforms | web,Android,iOS | Android,iOS |
| Ease Of Use | very easy to learn | requires expert technical knowledge |
| Is Open Source | – | ✔ |
| Support Included | ✔ | – |
| Review Pros |
1. Rapid Test Automation: Users can automate most test cases quickly without needing expertise in specific languages or frameworks. 2. Customer Support: The support team is highly responsive and easily accessible directly through the platform. 3. Ease of Use: The platform is user-friendly, requiring minimal training to handle. 4. Test Step Grouping: This feature streamlines the development of new scripts by grouping test steps. 5. No-Script Automation: Offers a codeless approach to test automation, making it accessible to non-technical users. 6. Integration Capabilities: Testsigma allows for seamless integration with various tools, enhancing the automation suite. 7. Natural Language Processing (NLP): Testsigma uses NLP for test cases, making it intuitive to write tests in plain English. 8. Accessibility: It caters to users with non-technical backgrounds, allowing them to learn and use the platform effectively. 9. End-to-End Testing: It supports comprehensive testing, including validation of OTPs via Email and SMS. 10. Custom Functionality: Users can import custom code to extend functionality when required actions are not available. | N/A |
| Review Cons |
1. Limited Database Testing: Currently, Testsigma does not support direct database testing, though some validation can be done using custom functions. 2. Reporting Features: The reporting capabilities are somewhat limited and could be improved. 3. Performance Issues: Some users have reported slower execution times and non-functional cloud devices. 4. End-to-End Testing Complexity: While possible, some users find end-to-end testing to be challenging. 5. Salesforce Integration: There is a need for improved integration features with Salesforce. 6. Ticket Tracking: Improvements could be made in how user-raised tickets are tracked. 7. Desktop Application Automation: Testsigma does not currently support the automation of desktop applications. 8. Element Inspection Limitations: Some elements cannot be inspected directly, requiring workarounds like Sikuli for interaction. 9. Occasional Errors: Users have encountered intermittent errors, sometimes due to platform maintenance or upgrades. 10. Lack of Transparency: There is a need for better communication regarding maintenance and updates that may affect test performance. | N/A |
Pricing Overview of Testsigma and Detox
Testsigma Pricing Model
Testsigma offers a tiered pricing structure to accommodate a variety of user needs, from small projects to large-scale enterprise testing requirements. The tiers include:
- Free Plan: Ideal for small projects, offering basic testing capabilities and resources.
- Pro Plan: Targets growing teams, providing unlimited automated testing minutes, numerous device and browser combinations, parallel testing, and integration options.
- Enterprise Plan: Serves large teams and TCOEs with advanced security, unlimited storage, custom data retention, and dedicated support.
Both the Pro and Enterprise plans necessitate direct contact with Testsigma for personalized pricing, which suggests a custom pricing strategy that adapts to the size and complexity of the user’s testing needs.
Detox Pricing Model
Detox operates on a completely different model, being a:
- Free Open Source Software: It is available at no cost and is maintained by the community. Detox does not have a structured pricing plan as it relies on open-source contributions.
Comparison of Pricing Models
When comparing the pricing models of Testsigma and Detox, several key differences and commonalities stand out:
Common Points:
- Accessibility for Small Projects: Both Testsigma and Detox offer solutions for smaller projects or teams. Testsigma provides a Free plan with limited features, while Detox is entirely free and open source.
- Focus on Automated Testing: Each product emphasizes the importance of automated testing in the software development lifecycle.
Key Differences:
- Pricing Structure: Testsigma utilizes a tiered pricing model with distinct plans to cater to different team sizes and requirements, while Detox is a free, open-source tool without any cost associated with its use.
- Customization: Testsigma offers customized pricing for its Pro and Enterprise plans, indicating a more tailored approach depending on the user’s specific needs. Detox, being open-source, does not have customizable pricing tiers.
- Enterprise Support: Testsigma’s Enterprise plan includes dedicated support and advanced features suitable for larger organizations. Detox, as an open-source tool, relies on community support and contributions, which may not provide the same level of dedicated service.
- Payment Model: Testsigma likely operates on a subscription-based model, as is common with SaaS platforms offering Pro and Enterprise plans. Detox, on the other hand, does not require payment or subscriptions.
Conclusion
The primary distinction between Testsigma and Detox lies in the pricing models and the level of support and customization offered. Testsigma provides a structured, tiered approach with the possibility of customization and dedicated support for enterprise clients. Detox, being open-source, offers a cost-free solution without formal support channels, relying on the community for maintenance and assistance. Users must consider their project size, budget, and need for professional support when choosing between these two testing solutions.
