You are evaluating a user interface screenshot for objective rendering defects.
Check only for these visible issue categories: viewport_cropping, container_clipping, text_overflow, element_overlap, obscured_actionable_control, or broken_responsive_reflow. Do not report subjective design preferences, copywriting concerns, or accessibility assumptions.
If there is one visible issue, return its category and the tight affected region on a normalized 0 to 1000 grid. If none of these issues is visible, return has_issue=false and null category and region values.
Return only data matching the supplied JSON schema. Do not describe your reasoning.
Blue marks the seeded defect region. Orange marks the model’s returned region when available.
Holo3 122B A10B
H Company · holo3-122b-a10b
Correct
Latency
1.69 s
Category
viewport cropping
Localization IoU
0.000
Cost
$0.00038
Attempts
1
{"has_issue":true,"category":"viewport_cropping","region":{"x":41,"y":867,"width":959,"height":133}, "description": "The 'Flight update' section is partially cut off at the bottom of the screen, indicating a viewport cropping issue."}
Grok 4.5
xAI · x-ai/grok-4.5
Correct
Latency
6.35 s
Category
container clipping
Localization IoU
0.000
Cost
$0.0014
Attempts
1
{"has_issue":true,"category":"container_clipping","region":{"x":40,"y":820,"width":920,"height":90},"description":"Blue banner text is clipped by the overlapping red flight update banner at the bottom."}
GPT-5.4
OpenAI · openai/gpt-5.4
Correct
Latency
12.15 s
Category
element overlap
Localization IoU
0.000
Cost
$0.0077
Attempts
1
{"has_issue":true,"category":"element_overlap","region":{"x":46,"y":852,"width":908,"height":63},"description":"A red update banner overlaps and obscures content within the blue card near the bottom of the screen."}
Gemini 3.6 Flash
Google AI Studio · google/gemini-3.6-flash
Correct
Latency
9.48 s
Category
obscured actionable control
Localization IoU
0.984
Cost
$0.0046
Attempts
1
{
"has_issue": true,
"category": "obscured_actionable_control",
"region": {
"x": 46,
"y": 850,
"width": 908,
"height": 65
},
"description": "The 'Flight update' banner overlaps and obscures the main action button at the bottom of the screen."
}
GPT-5.6 Sol
OpenAI · openai/gpt-5.6-sol
Correct
Latency
10.07 s
Category
obscured actionable control
Localization IoU
0.359
Cost
$0.0087
Attempts
1
{"has_issue":true,"category":"obscured_actionable_control","region":{"x":46,"y":869,"width":910,"height":23},"description":"The red flight-update banner overlaps and obscures the lower portion of the blue action button."}
GPT-5.6 Luna
OpenAI · openai/gpt-5.6-luna
Correct
Latency
9.53 s
Category
obscured actionable control
Localization IoU
0.978
Cost
$0.00019
Attempts
1
{"has_issue":true,"category":"obscured_actionable_control","region":{"x":46,"y":850,"width":908,"height":64},"description":"The red flight update banner visibly covers the lower portion of the blue actionable button beneath it."}
Claude Sonnet 5
Anthropic · anthropic/claude-sonnet-5
Correct
Latency
10.05 s
Category
element overlap
Localization IoU
0.000
Cost
$0.0035
Attempts
1
{"has_issue":true,"category":"element_overlap","region":{"x":18,"y":718,"width":354,"height":55},"description":"The red 'Flight update' notification banner overlaps the blue 'Check-in' button above it, obscuring its text."}
Claude Opus 5
Anthropic · anthropic/claude-opus-5
Incorrect
Latency
12.34 s
Category
element overlap
Localization IoU
0.000
Cost
$0.0089
Attempts
1
{"has_issue":true,"category":"element_overlap","region":{"x":46,"y":1808,"width":908,"height":150},"description":"The red 'Flight update' banner overlaps and hides the blue 'Check in' button text at the bottom of the screen."}
region must be contained in normalized 0..1000 coordinates. has_issue=true requires a category and normalized region.
Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview
Google AI Studio · google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview
Correct
Latency
17.76 s
Category
element overlap
Localization IoU
0.000
Cost
$0.0033
Attempts
1
{"has_issue": true, "category": "element_overlap", "region": {"x": 46, "y": 850, "width": 907, "height": 64}, "description": "The red 'Flight update' banner is overlapping the blue 'Check in' button at the bottom of the screen."}