5 February 2024 Leave a comment Tool comparisons
In the dynamic realm of test automation, Testsigma and Sauce Labs stand out as distinct solutions tailored to modern development needs. Testsigma offers a low-code, AI-driven environment for codeless testing across mobile and web applications, boasting features such as AI-based automation and physical device testing.
On the other hand, Sauce Labs caters to a broad spectrum of testing requirements with a robust set of tools including real device clouds and computer vision capabilities, emphasizing its strength in CI/CD integration. Both platforms promise to streamline the quality assurance process, yet they differ in their approach to test automation and the specific features they offer.
Latest update: 1/31/2024, 5:18:29 PM
We do not guarantee the accuracy, reliability, or completeness of the information presented on our website. This includes prices, product specifications, and availability, which are subject to change. The reviews on this site are collected from g2.com and crozdesk.com and summarized by us.
Feature comparison of Testsigma and Sauce Labs
| Feature | Testsigma | Sauce Labs |
|---|---|---|
| Free Plan | ✔ | – |
| On Premise | ✔ | ✔ |
| Device Farm | ✔ | ✔ |
| Scheduler | ✔ | N/A |
| Test Recorder | ✔ | N/A |
| Physical Device Testing | ✔ | N/A |
| No Code | ✔ | ✔ |
| Uses Ai | ✔ | ✔ |
| Generates Reports | ✔ | ✔ |
| Uses Computer Vision | N/A | ✔ |
| Platforms | web,Android,iOS | web,Android,iOS |
| Ease Of Use | very easy to learn | easy to learn |
| Is Open Source | – | – |
| Support Included | ✔ | ✔ |
| Review Pros |
1. Rapid Test Automation: Users can automate most test cases quickly without needing expertise in specific languages or frameworks. 2. Customer Support: The support team is highly responsive and easily accessible directly through the platform. 3. Ease of Use: The platform is user-friendly, requiring minimal training to handle. 4. Test Step Grouping: This feature streamlines the development of new scripts by grouping test steps. 5. No-Script Automation: Offers a codeless approach to test automation, making it accessible to non-technical users. 6. Integration Capabilities: Testsigma allows for seamless integration with various tools, enhancing the automation suite. 7. Natural Language Processing (NLP): Testsigma uses NLP for test cases, making it intuitive to write tests in plain English. 8. Accessibility: It caters to users with non-technical backgrounds, allowing them to learn and use the platform effectively. 9. End-to-End Testing: It supports comprehensive testing, including validation of OTPs via Email and SMS. 10. Custom Functionality: Users can import custom code to extend functionality when required actions are not available. |
1. Easy to integrate with existing codebases, enhancing the adaptability for teams. 2. Offers a high degree of versatility for testing across different browsers, devices, and platforms. 3. Provides an intuitive user interface that is frequently updated based on user feedback. 4. Regularly introduces new features and improvements to the service. 5. Boasts a supportive community for troubleshooting and user assistance. 6. Enables effective cross-browser and cross-platform testing without complex setups. 7. Supports the latest web browsers and mobile operating systems for both forward and backward compatibility testing. 8. Facilitates parallel execution, allowing numerous instances to run simultaneously, which significantly reduces test suite execution time. 9. Features video recordings of tests to help identify where failures occur. 10. Includes a platform configurator to assist in running test suites on real mobile applications. |
| Review Cons |
1. Limited Database Testing: Currently, Testsigma does not support direct database testing, though some validation can be done using custom functions. 2. Reporting Features: The reporting capabilities are somewhat limited and could be improved. 3. Performance Issues: Some users have reported slower execution times and non-functional cloud devices. 4. End-to-End Testing Complexity: While possible, some users find end-to-end testing to be challenging. 5. Salesforce Integration: There is a need for improved integration features with Salesforce. 6. Ticket Tracking: Improvements could be made in how user-raised tickets are tracked. 7. Desktop Application Automation: Testsigma does not currently support the automation of desktop applications. 8. Element Inspection Limitations: Some elements cannot be inspected directly, requiring workarounds like Sikuli for interaction. 9. Occasional Errors: Users have encountered intermittent errors, sometimes due to platform maintenance or upgrades. 10. Lack of Transparency: There is a need for better communication regarding maintenance and updates that may affect test performance. |
1. The cost can be high due to the reliance on virtual machines. 2. Users may occasionally encounter server errors. 3. Customer support response times can be slow. 4. Frequent changes in account managers can disrupt service continuity. 5. Lacks an option to export test reports in formats such as TestNG, Cucumber, and Extent directly from Sauce Labs. 6. The process of copying usernames and passwords from the profile can be cumbersome. 7. Errors during testing can occur, requiring users to rely on video features for debugging. 8. Does not provide email triage for report notifications of test suites. 9. Running real mobile device tests with the same web browser suite can present challenges. 10. The time taken for script execution can be a concern for some users. |
Comparative Analysis of Testsigma and Sauce Labs Pricing Models
Testsigma Pricing Overview
Testsigma provides an AI-driven test automation platform with a three-tier pricing structure:
- Free Plan: This plan is designed for smaller projects with limited testing needs.
- Pro Plan: Tailored for growing teams, this plan offers unlimited automated testing minutes and supports a wide range of device and browser combinations.
- Enterprise Plan: Targeted at large organizations or TCOEs, it offers advanced features such as enhanced security and unlimited storage.
Both the Pro and Enterprise plans require direct contact with the sales team for personalized pricing.
Sauce Labs Pricing Overview
Sauce Labs offers a Continuous Testing Cloud with several plans:
- Live Testing Plan: Starting at $39/month, this plan is for manual testing with unlimited users and minutes.
- Virtual Cloud Plan: Priced at $149/month, it introduces automated testing capabilities.
- Real Device Cloud Plan: At $199/month, it provides access to testing on real mobile devices.
Enterprise-specific needs are addressed through direct contact for premium features and support. Sauce Labs also includes overage charges and supports open source projects with free accounts.
Comparison of Pricing Models
Common Points:
- Tiered Pricing: Both Testsigma and Sauce Labs offer multiple pricing tiers, catering to different sizes and needs of testing teams.
- Enterprise Customization: They provide customized solutions for enterprise-level clients, requiring direct contact for pricing details.
- Free Options: Each has a free offering, with Testsigma providing a Free plan and Sauce Labs supporting open source projects with free accounts.
Differences:
- Pricing Transparency: Sauce Labs lists specific prices for its initial plans, whereas Testsigma requires potential customers to contact sales for Pro and Enterprise plan pricing.
- Overage Charges: Sauce Labs specifies overage charges for minute-limited plans, a detail not mentioned in Testsigma’s model.
- Billing Flexibility: Sauce Labs offers both monthly and annual billing options, while Testsigma does not explicitly state its billing cycles.
- Support for Open Source: Sauce Labs explicitly mentions support for open source projects, which is not a noted aspect of Testsigma’s pricing model.
- Automated Testing in Base Plans: Testsigma’s Free plan includes some level of automated testing, while Sauce Labs’ lowest-tier plan is limited to manual testing.
- Parallel Testing: Sauce Labs’ plans start with one parallel test, with the option to add more. Testsigma includes parallel execution in its Pro plan, but specifics are not provided without contacting sales.
Conclusion
Readers should note that while both Testsigma and Sauce Labs offer tiered pricing structures suitable for a range of team sizes and needs, key differences lie in the transparency of pricing, the presence of overage charges, and the support for open source projects. Sauce Labs provides more upfront pricing information for its lower-tier plans, while Testsigma emphasizes personalized solutions with a need to contact sales for detailed pricing. Understanding these differences will help potential customers select the platform that best fits their testing requirements and budget considerations.
