31 January 2024 Leave a comment Tool comparisons
In the world of software testing, choosing the right automation tool can be pivotal. Katalon offers a comprehensive quality management platform with AI-augmented features and visual testing, designed for teams seeking a balance between low-code and full-code capabilities.
It’s versatile, supporting web, Android, and iOS platforms, but some advanced features require a paid license. On the other hand, Detox shines as a free, open-source framework tailored for gray box E2E testing, especially for React Native mobile apps. While it demands coding skills, it promises to reduce flakiness in tests with its automatic synchronization and cross-platform support.
Latest update: 1/29/2024, 3:34:32 PM
We do not guarantee the accuracy, reliability, or completeness of the information presented on our website. This includes prices, product specifications, and availability, which are subject to change. The reviews on this site are collected from g2.com and crozdesk.com and summarized by us.
Feature comparison of Katalon and Detox
| Feature | Katalon | Detox |
|---|---|---|
| Free Plan | ✔ | ✔ |
| On Premise | ✔ | ✔ |
| Device Farm | ✔ | – |
| Scheduler | ✔ | – |
| No Code | ✔ | – |
| Uses Ai | ✔ | – |
| Generates Reports | ✔ | – |
| Uses Computer Vision | ✔ | – |
| Platforms | web,Android,iOS | Android,iOS |
| Ease Of Use | easy to learn | requires expert technical knowledge |
| Is Open Source | – | ✔ |
| Support Included | ✔ | – |
| Review Pros |
– Reduced Effort in Test Maintenance: Users report that Katalon simplifies the creation and maintenance of reusable methods, which can reduce time and effort significantly. – Built-in Reporting Features: The platform automatically captures snapshots on test failures, which enhances the efficiency of reporting. – Comprehensive Test Features: Offers features like Record, Object Spy, and Frame Handling, which streamline the testing process. – Low Learning Curve: Katalon is accessible to manual testers, allowing them to transition to automation testing with minimal training. – Cross-Functional Testing Support: It supports UI, API, and Mobile testing within a single platform, reducing the need to manage different tools for different types of testing. – Community and Customer Support: There is strong community support for the free version and dedicated customer support for the paid version. – Facilitates Cross-Functional Roles: Enables testers to handle both manual and automated testing, effectively becoming cross-functional team members. – CI/CD Integration: For those who opt for the paid version, it offers Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment integration. – Codeless Automation: Provides a codeless automation option, making it accessible for teams with limited coding knowledge. – Efficiency in Test Execution: Users find that Katalon allows for faster test execution compared to manual testing, enabling more extensive and frequent testing. | N/A |
| Review Cons |
– Separate Licensing: Some users find the need for separate licenses for different features to be a disadvantage. – Cost for Advanced Features: Advanced features like CI/CD integration and Visual Testing require a paid license. – Mobile Execution Issues: There have been reports of instability during mobile test execution, where sessions unexpectedly close. – High Resource Usage: Users with less powerful hardware have experienced performance issues, indicating the platform may require substantial system resources. – Lack of Support for Legacy Systems: Katalon currently does not support automation testing for legacy Java UIs, which can be a limitation for some organizations. – Limited TestOps Analytics: The free version has limitations on the analytical results available through TestOps, pushing users towards the paid version for full functionality. – Separate Licensing for Cloud Features: Features like Parallel Cloud Execution and Cloud Tunnelling require additional licensing, which can increase costs. – Limited Free Features: Some users feel that the most valuable features are locked behind the paid version, which can be a barrier for smaller teams or individual users. – Hardware Demands: The platform’s demand on hardware resources can lead to slower performance on less capable machines. – No Bundled Packages: Users would prefer bundled packages for the various Katalon products to simplify licensing and possibly reduce costs. | N/A |
Pricing Model Comparison: Katalon vs. Detox
Katalon Pricing Overview
Katalon offers a tiered pricing model aimed at different user groups, with a range of features corresponding to each tier. The Starter Plan is free and suitable for small teams or beginners, offering basic test automation features. For more advanced needs, the Premium Plan starts at $167 per month (when billed annually) and caters to professional-grade testing requirements. For enterprise-grade capabilities, the Ultimate Plan is available, which requires custom pricing. Annual billing comes with a discount of up to 25%, and Katalon provides package deals and discounts for new customers. This pricing model is comprehensive, covering extensive features for web, API, mobile, and desktop testing, including AI-powered and visual testing options.
Detox Pricing Overview
Detox operates on a completely different model as it is a free open-source software. As such, it does not have a traditional pricing model or tiered plans. Users can download and use Detox without any financial commitment, making it accessible for individuals and teams of all sizes. The open-source nature of Detox implies that it relies on community support and contributions for updates and features.
Comparison of Pricing Models
Common Points:
- Accessibility for Beginners: Both Katalon and Detox offer solutions that are accessible to beginners. Katalon provides a free Starter Plan, while Detox is entirely free.
- Support for Various Testing Types: Each tool supports a range of testing types, including web and mobile.
Differences:
- Pricing Structure: Katalon employs a tiered pricing strategy with free, Premium, and Ultimate plans, each offering progressively more advanced features. Detox, however, is free for all users.
- Cost of Advanced Features: With Katalon, advanced features come at a cost, starting at $167 per month for the Premium Plan and requiring custom pricing for the Ultimate Plan. Detox offers its features for free, but being open-source, might not have the same breadth of advanced features as a paid product like Katalon.
- Enterprise Support: Katalon’s Ultimate Plan is designed for enterprise users and includes enterprise-grade features, which is not explicitly offered by Detox.
- Community vs. Professional Support: Detox is community-driven, meaning support and development are provided by the community of users. In contrast, Katalon offers professional support and development, especially at the Premium and Ultimate levels.
- Discounts and Package Deals: Katalon provides discounts for annual billing and package deals, which are not applicable to Detox since it is free.
- Custom Pricing: Katalon offers custom pricing for its Ultimate Plan, which is tailored to large organizations’ specific needs. Detox does not have any pricing, so the concept of custom pricing does not apply.
In summary, Katalon’s pricing model is structured to cater to a wide range of users, from individuals and small teams to large enterprises, with a clear path for scaling up as testing requirements grow. Detox, on the other hand, is ideal for those who are looking for a no-cost solution and are willing to rely on community support and contributions for their testing needs.
