Ensuring the Integrity of Automated Test Results

Ensuring the Integrity of Automated Test Results

3 July 2024 Stephan Petzl Leave a comment QA

Test automation is a critical component of modern software development, helping teams ensure the quality and reliability of their applications. However, the effectiveness of test automation can be compromised if the tests are not properly validated. This article provides guidance on how to audit test automation code to prevent the generation of fake results.

Key Practices to Prevent Fake Test Results

1. Conduct Thorough Code Reviews

Code reviews are essential in identifying placeholder code and ensuring that the tests are meaningful. During the review process, team members can catch instances where assertions are incorrectly used, such as assert true == true. Code reviews should be a standard practice for all test automation code, similar to production code.

  • Management and Senior Managers: Ensure that time and effort are allocated for code reviews.
  • Team Leaders: Supervise and enforce the practice of code reviews.
  • Team Members: Participate in technical reviews, peer reviews, and walkthroughs.

2. Apply Coding Standards and Best Practices

Treat automation code with the same rigor as production code by adhering to coding standards and best practices. This includes writing clear, maintainable, and testable code. Encourage the use of techniques such as “Red, Green, Refactor” to ensure that each test is necessary and correctly implemented.

3. Implement Test-First and Pair Testing Methodologies

Adopting test-first methodologies, such as Test-Driven Development (TDD), ensures that tests are written before the code they validate. This approach helps prevent the creation of irrelevant tests. Additionally, pair testing, where a developer and a tester work together, can enhance the quality of both the code and the tests.

4. Utilize Code Quality Tools

Leverage code quality tools to analyze your code base and test coverage. Tools like Code Climate and Codecov can help identify areas for improvement and enforce coding standards. These tools can also detect patterns such as unused page objects or redundant assertions.

5. Regularly Audit Existing Test Code

Conduct periodic audits of existing test automation code to ensure continued adherence to quality standards. This can involve reviewing all test code as if it were new, and developing strategies to address any identified issues.

6. Promote a Culture of Quality

Encourage a culture that values quality through education, documentation of good practices, and recognition of efforts. Consider incorporating code quality into performance reviews and providing educational opportunities such as lunch-and-learns or seminars.


By implementing these practices, teams can significantly reduce the risk of generating fake test results and ensure the reliability of their test automation efforts. Regular code reviews, adherence to coding standards, and the use of quality tools are all essential components of a robust test automation strategy.

For teams looking to streamline their test automation processes, Repeato offers a no-code test automation tool for iOS and Android. Repeato allows users to create, run, and maintain automated tests quickly and efficiently, leveraging computer vision and AI. This tool can help teams ensure the quality of their applications without the need for extensive coding, making it an excellent choice for quality assurance.

Like this article? there’s more where that came from!