8 January 2024 Leave a comment Tools & Frameworks
In the dynamic world of mobile development, ensuring that an application performs flawlessly across different platforms and devices is crucial. This is where mobile test automation tools come into play, providing the means to execute comprehensive and repetitive testing scenarios efficiently.
Whether you’re a developer, QA professional, or part of a mobile app development team, the right set of app test automation tools can revolutionize the way you validate app functionality and user experience.
Our latest article, “14 Cross-Platform Mobile Test Automation Tools,” offers an insightful mobile test automation tools comparison. We dive into the features, advantages, and use cases of leading platforms, including Repeato, Accelq, Ranorex Studio, Mobot, Detox, Sofy, Waldo, Bitbar, Perfecto, Appium, Applitools, Marathon, TestComplete, and Sauce Labs. Our focus is on equipping you with the knowledge to select the best mobile app test automation tools that align with your project requirements.
From AI-driven frameworks to no-code solutions, we cover a gamut of mobile application test automation tools designed to streamline your automation testing mobile apps process. Whether you’re looking to enhance CI/CD integration, leverage cloud-based testing, or require support for specific programming languages, our curated list addresses various needs within the mobile app automation testing landscape. Join us as we explore these powerful tools to elevate your app testing strategy.
Latest update: 12/18/2023, 1:08:27 PM
We do not guarantee the accuracy, reliability, or completeness of the information presented on our website. This includes prices, product specifications, and availability, which are subject to change.
A Comparison of 14 Cross plattform mobile test automation tools
| Product Name | Short Description | Platforms | Pros | Cons | Pricing Summary | Free Plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Repeato | No-code mobile test automation tool using computer vision and machine learning. | Android, iOS | Intuitive UI, cross-platform compatibility, CI/CD integration. | Limited iOS system window interaction, enterprise-level CI/CD tools. | Free plan available. Basic: €70/user/month, Pro: €120/user/month, Enterprise: Custom pricing. | ✔ |
| ACCELQ | AI-driven codeless test automation platform for web, API, mobile, and Salesforce. | Web, Android, iOS | Efficiency, self-healing, improved test coverage, object repository. | Java integration, Desktop UI issues, limited language support. | Trials available; Enterprise plan customizable. Contact for pricing. | – |
| Ranorex Studio | Automated UI test suite for mobile, web, desktop apps with cross-platform test suites. | Web, Android, iOS | Effective Ranorex Spy tool, stable scripts, cross-browser support. | Only supports C#, high cost, persistent system bugs. | Licensing model: Studio, Enterprise, Runtime. Contact sales for pricing. | – |
| Mobot | Mobile QA with robot-driven testing, managed services, and insights. | Web, Android, iOS | Real robot testing, 300+ device access, premium support. | Limited details provided. | Live: $249/month, Managed: $1,999/month, Insights: $1,999/month. | – |
| Detox | Gray box E2E testing framework for React Native apps on Android and iOS. | Android, iOS | Cross-platform support, automatic synchronization, CI-friendly. | Requires JavaScript coding, no explicit AI or computer vision. | Free open-source software. | ✔ |
| Sofy | No-code mobile app testing with AI-powered automation and real devices. | Android, iOS | Responsive support, robust mobile testing, CI/CD integration. | Limited web testing features, minute-based pricing system. | Starter: $549/month, Pro: $1,499/month, Enterprise: Custom pricing. | – |
| Waldo | No-code mobile test automation with an intuitive interface and advanced features. | Android, iOS | Real user perspective, assertion feature, excellent support. | Continuous adaptation, no automation for edge cases. | Free manual testing; automated plans require demo or contact. | ✔ |
| Bitbar | Cloud-based mobile and web app testing with a wide selection of devices and browsers. | Web, Android, iOS | Cross-browser support, user-friendly, cost-effective. | Compatibility issues with IE 11, customer support variability. | Live: $39/month, Unlimited: $177/month, Enterprise: Custom pricing. | – |
| Perfecto | Enterprise test automation with cloud-based testing labs and AI-driven analytics. | Web, Android, iOS | Framework integration, device availability, user-friendly dashboard. | Costly service, learning curve, device update frequency. | Live: $83/month, Automate: $125/month, Enterprise: Contact sales. | – |
| Appium | Open-source test automation framework for cross-platform testing. | Web, Android, iOS | Cross-platform support, extensible architecture, WebDriver compatibility. | Requires coding knowledge, no explicit AI or report generation. | Free open-source software. | ✔ |
| Applitools | AI-powered test automation with Visual AI and cloud-based test infrastructure. | Web, Android, iOS | Easy to use, customer support, cross-browser and device testing. | Sluggish on slow connections, snapshot quality issues. | Starter plan and free account with limitations. Contact for enterprise pricing. | ✔ |
| Marathon | Test execution tool with batching, device pools, and sharding for Android and iOS. | Android, iOS | Test batching, device pools, test sharding. | Requires configuration knowledge, no explicit AI or computer vision. | Free open-source software. | ✔ |
| TestComplete | (Discontinued) Automated UI testing tool with AI-powered object recognition. | Web, Android, iOS | Was versatile, supported a wide range of platforms. | Discontinued in mid of 2023. | Not available. | – |
| Sauce Labs | Mobile testing tools with real device cloud, emulators, simulators, and error monitoring. | Web, Android, iOS | Versatility for different browsers/devices, intuitive UI, community support. | High cost, server errors, slow support response times. | Live: $39/month, Virtual Cloud: $149/month, Real Device: $199/month. | – |
Let’s take a closer look at the 14 14 Cross platform mobile test automation tools:
Repeato
Mobile applications are integral to both personal and professional environments, necessitating robust testing to ensure a flawless user experience. Mobile test automation tools such as Repeato streamline this process, providing a no-code, efficient solution for automating mobile app testing on physical devices.
Simplified UI Test Creation for Apps
Repeato’s intuitive interface allows for simple test creation without coding expertise, making it a go-to choice for automation testing of mobile apps. With Repeato, users can automate tests by recording interactions directly from their mobile device or simulator, which is then mirrored onto the desktop.
Compatibility and Integration
Designed for compatibility, Repeato supports multiple frameworks like Flutter and React Native, catering to various development needs. Integration with CI/CD pipelines is seamless, with a CLI headless test runner for cloud execution, compatible with platforms such as GitHub Actions and CircleCI.
Cost-Effective Testing Solution
Highlighting its cost-effectiveness, Repeato provides a comparison demonstrating savings in automating and maintaining tests, significantly reducing the time and resources required when compared to traditional methods.
User Experience and Feedback
The tool has garnered positive feedback for its ability to reduce testing time and manage complex app configurations easily, with users like Stefan Wolfrath and Phil Boyd endorsing its effectiveness.
Streamlining Mobile App Testing
Acknowledging the importance of delivering functional and user-friendly applications, Repeato offers a simplified alternative to mobile test automation services, especially beneficial for those with limited technical knowledge. It uses machine learning to enhance test robustness, allowing for efficient test recording and maintenance.
Incorporating Repeato into QA workflows is straightforward, from downloading Repeato-Studio to executing tests and generating reports. Its user-friendly approach positions it as a valuable asset in the mobile test automation tools comparison, particularly for teams seeking a streamlined, no-code solution for app test automation.
Pros and cons of Repeato
Pros of Repeato
- Simple and intuitive interface
- Easy setup process, no complex configurations needed
- Accessibility for both developers and non-programmers
- Supports various testing methods like clicks, drags and scripting
- Exceptional stability, no crashes or driver issues
- Regular updates with bug fixes and excellent customer support
- Great for mobile app testing, with efficient script creation
- Allows for hundreds of additional tests each day
- User-friendly, with easy adaptation and no initial setup required
- Recognizes elements using visual fingerprints for testing
- Allows for reusability and easy maintenance of scripts
- No prior training or complex coding skills needed
Cons of Repeato
- Some limitations for iOS applications when tapping on any system window outside of the app
- Access to CI/CD tools is only available at the enterprise level
- Occasional unknown errors while performing basic tasks, although they are quickly remedied in the next version.
Ranorex Studio
Ranorex Studio stands out in the realm of mobile test automation tools, offering a robust suite for automating mobile, web, and desktop testing with a focus on user interface elements. It ensures that applications deliver consistent performance across various platforms, including mobile devices.
Mobile App Automation Testing with Ranorex
Ranorex Studio facilitates the automation of native, mobile web, and hybrid app testing. Its cross-platform test suites and support for real and emulated Android device testing make it a comprehensive solution for mobile app test automation tools.
Features Simplifying Test Automation for Mobile Apps
- Test creation is versatile, with options to record, code, or use a combination of both.
- End-to-end testing capabilities reduce the need for complex context switching.
- Integration with Continuous Integration (CI) environments streamlines the testing process.
Advanced Mobile Testing Capabilities
- Simulate real user interactions with common gestures.
- Ranorex Studio combats device fragmentation with RanoreXPath to maintain test accuracy despite UI changes.
- Test device-specific parameters to ensure comprehensive coverage.
Efficient Setup and Seamless Integration
- Ranorex requires no device modification, providing a hassle-free setup.
- The tool includes an instrumentation wizard for quick device setup and offers an intuitive approach to test creation.
Why Ranorex is a Preferred Choice
- Its integrated toolset and compatibility with a wide range of technologies.
- Data-driven testing enhances the connection between test data and workflows.
- Parallel testing capabilities allow simultaneous execution on iOS and Android devices.
Recognition and Global Adoption
Ranorex Studio has earned industry recognition for its high customer satisfaction and is utilized by over 4000 companies globally, emphasizing its reliability as a mobile test automation service.
Resources and Support
Ranorex keeps users up-to-date with the latest developments and provides extensive support, including how-to videos, user guides, training certifications, and a user forum. Additional educational resources such as webinars and eBooks are available to enrich users’ understanding of mobile test automation tools comparison and application.
By addressing the needs of mobile app automation testing, Ranorex Studio provides a valuable addition to the suite of test automation tools for mobile apps, helping streamline the testing process and ensure the quality of mobile applications.
Pros and cons of Ranorex Studio
Pros
- Ranorex Spy tool is effective for identifying and locating XPath, providing an edge over some other automation tools.
- Enables creation of stable automation scripts that are less affected by updates compared to tools like Selenium.
- Powerful tool that can cover almost all types of desktop applications.
- Provides the flexibility to implement code using Ranorex API as well as within Ranorex Studio.
- Offers support for automation of web and mobile applications in addition to desktop apps.
- Ranorex can be cost-effective if the infrastructure and approach are optimized.
- Features easy click and recording capabilities for actions of the tested application.
- Provides a variety of free online training sessions for all experience levels and helpful support.
- Facilitates the transition from manual to automated testing, potentially increasing test coverage and efficiency.
- Simplifies test creation, especially for those with less programming knowledge, and supports cross-browser testing.
Cons
- Ranorex only supports C# and is limited to Windows, lacking support for Mac OS.
- Some users experience difficulties when recording actions on applications using multiple technologies.
- Some users report receiving no tangible benefits from using Ranorex in certain scenarios.
- The cost of Ranorex can be high, which may be a barrier for smaller teams or businesses.
- Users have reported experiencing persistent bugs and issues within the system over the years.
- Communication with support has been challenging for some users, with difficulties in resolving issues.
- Sales representative turnover can lead to inconsistencies in customer service.
- Reporting functionality in Ranorex is criticized for not scaling well with larger tests.
- While Ranorex is flexible, some users feel that this flexibility is necessary to work around its shortcomings.
- Compatibility with all desired technologies should be thoroughly tested, as some users have found limitations in Ranorex’s ability to interact with certain elements.
Mobot
Mobot’s innovative approach to mobile test automation tools offers a comprehensive suite of services for quality assurance (QA), engineering, and marketing teams in the mobile app development sector. By employing real robots, Mobot enhances app test automation services, ensuring extensive device coverage and streamlined workflows.
Enhancing QA with Mobot Live
Mobot Live stands out as a self-service platform for automation testing of mobile apps, offering over 300 iOS and Android devices for testing. This service automates repetitive tasks such as recording and screenshotting, providing QA teams with a live robot camera feed for real-time monitoring.
Engineering Efficiency with Mobot Managed
Mobot Managed delivers a fully-managed mobile app automation testing service, tailored for engineering teams tackling complex use cases. Mechanical robots are utilized to expedite test processes, boasting a testing speed five times faster than manual approaches and achieving unparalleled testing coverage.
Marketing Insights with Mobot Insights
Mobot Insights aids marketing teams by monitoring mobile campaigns and providing detailed reports on issues, helping to prevent potential revenue losses. The service includes features like automated JIRA ticket creation, enabling effective bug tracking and resolution.
Diverse Use Cases
Mobot’s tools support various functionalities, from Google Account Authentication to Biometric Security Features, ensuring comprehensive mobile app test automation tools are available for different scenarios.
Proven Results with Robot-Assisted Testing
Leading development teams have witnessed improved testing efficiency and app stability through Mobot’s services. Testimonials from companies such as Persona and MySwimPro affirm the value added by Mobot’s robot-powered testing.
For a closer look at how Mobot can transform your mobile QA processes, reach out for a demo. Explore further details on Mobot’s offerings, company information, and educational resources to make an informed decision when comparing mobile test automation tools.
Mobot, headquartered in New York, NY, continues to push the boundaries of mobile QA with their robot-powered testing solutions, holding a steadfast commitment to innovation in the field.
Detox by Wix
Detox stands out as a proficient mobile test automation tool, specifically engineered to enhance gray box end-to-end (E2E) testing for mobile applications. With a focus on React Native apps, Detox supports both Android and iOS platforms, offering a reliable solution for developers aiming to simulate user interactions within their mobile applications.
Simplified Test Writing with JavaScript
Detox enables writing E2E tests in JavaScript, reflecting real user interactions. This approach ensures that tests can seamlessly automate and verify user flows within the app, such as login processes, with precision and efficiency.
Key Features of Detox
- Cross-Platform Compatibility: Detox’s JavaScript-based testing is applicable for React Native applications on both Android and iOS.
- Enhanced Debugging: The async-await API simplifies the debugging of asynchronous tests.
- Automatic Synchronization: Reduces test flakiness by aligning with the app’s asynchronous operations.
- CI Integration: Detox is optimized for continuous integration environments, enhancing the development pipeline.
- Real Device and Simulator Testing: Detox tests can be executed on actual devices or simulators, though iOS real device support is in progress.
- Test Runner Flexibility: Although bundled with Jest, Detox provides adaptable APIs for various test runners.
React Native Support and Compatibility
Detox maintains compatibility with the latest React Native releases, officially supporting versions 0.70.x and 0.71.x, and strives to keep up with newer versions. Potential compatibility issues are actively addressed by the community and the Detox team.
Easy Integration and Comprehensive Resources
Setting up Detox is streamlined with a detailed Getting Started Guide, and extensive documentation is available on the Detox website. This fosters a deeper understanding of the tool’s capabilities and how it compares with other mobile test automation tools.
Community Engagement and Open-Source Contribution
As an open-source project, Detox encourages community contributions, from feature suggestions to bug fixes, and provides a Contribution Guide for active involvement.
Detox, as a mobile app automation testing framework, emphasizes reducing test flakiness and simplifying integration into CI/CD workflows. It stands as a compelling choice for developers seeking robust mobile test automation tools, particularly for React Native applications.
Features:
- Cross-Platform Support: Write E2E tests in JavaScript for React Native applications on both Android and iOS platforms.
- Debugging Made Simpler: Utilizes an async-await API that allows for setting breakpoints in asynchronous tests.
- Automatic Synchronization: Reduces test flakiness by automatically synchronizing with the app’s asynchronous operations.
- CI-Friendly: Compatible with continuous integration platforms like Travis CI, Circle CI, or Jenkins.
- Real Device Testing: Increases app confidence by testing on actual devices or simulators, providing a closer approximation to real user behavior.
Github stats:
- Forks: 1949
- Stars: 10711
- Commits: 4648
- Last commit on: 2023-12-19T15:39:08Z
Sofy
Sofy stands out as a comprehensive mobile test automation tool geared towards enhancing the efficiency and accuracy of the mobile app development lifecycle. It simplifies the mobile app automation testing process by providing a no-code platform that is accessible to professionals irrespective of their coding background.
Scriptless Test Automation Simplified
Sofy revolutionizes automation testing for mobile apps through a three-step scriptless automation process that includes:
- Selection from an extensive device lab to commence testing.
- One-click conversion of manual tests into automated ones.
- Execution of these automated tests across multiple devices, minimizing maintenance efforts.
Real Device Testing for Authentic Results
By offering access to actual Android and iOS devices, Sofy enables mobile app test automation tools to deliver real-world testing scenarios, moving beyond the limitations of emulators and simulators.
Advanced Features for Robust Testing
With self-healing testing capabilities, Sofy ensures that mobile application test automation tools can perform regression testing efficiently, adapting to code changes and maintaining a consistent user experience across varying device specifications.
Seamless Integrations and Customer Endorsements
Sofy integrates effortlessly with essential tools and applications, including CI/CD pipelines, tailoring to the diverse testing requirements of apps. Testimonials from companies like Innago and CoinMe highlight Sofy’s effectiveness in streamlining their QA processes and enhancing agile testing methodologies.
Expansive Resources and Easy Adoption
A rich repository of resources, including webinars and blog posts, is available to support users in adopting mobile test automation tools comparison best practices. Sofy’s invitation for a free trial or demo showcases its commitment to providing a user-friendly experience for mobile app test automation services.
By facilitating manual and ad-hoc testing, no-code automation, and UI validation against industry benchmarks, Sofy offers a solution that addresses the needs of QA engineers, engineering managers, and product managers, among others, in the realm of app test automation tools.
Pros and cons of Sofy
Pros
- The support team is highly responsive and provides solid assistance.
- Mobile testing capabilities are particularly strong.
- Enables creation of test data and handling conditional logic through a record-and-play feature.
- Integration with JIRA and CI/CD pipelines enhances workflow.
- Facilitates rapid increase in test coverage.
- The ability to make API requests within tests allows for more comprehensive testing scenarios.
- Described as a user-friendly no-code solution, making it accessible for startups and non-developers.
- Encourages best practices in test writing through collaboration with a technical account manager.
- Supports testing on real devices and can connect to other devices via Bluetooth.
- Actively listens to customer feedback and regularly introduces new, helpful features.
Cons
- Some users may find the product’s capabilities limited for cutting-edge or unique test cases.
- Web testing features are not as robust as mobile testing features.
- Issues with JIRA integration have been reported.
- The platform may require a learning curve and initial setup effort to integrate with existing CI flows.
- Test execution speed has been reported as somewhat slow by some users.
- Uses a minute-based pricing system, which may not suit all types of projects or budgets.
- Some users find the overall pricing to be on the higher side.
- Requires effort to automate test cases and connect physical devices via Bluetooth, despite the ease of use.
- The product is still growing and may not have all the desired features yet.
- Requires some technical effort to fully integrate test results with other continuous integration flows.
Waldo
Waldo emerges as a competent mobile test automation tool, offering a no-code interface that caters to both technical and non-technical team members. It simplifies the creation, execution, and maintenance of end-to-end tests for mobile applications, all through a web browser.
Streamlined Test Creation Process
Waldo allows users to upload their mobile app’s build, facilitating straightforward test scenario creation by simulating user interactions. These scenarios are essential for verifying the app’s functionality against expected user journeys. Subsequent builds are automatically tested for consistency and performance across various device configurations.
Efficient Issue Detection
With its robust issue identification capabilities, Waldo highlights discrepancies from the expected “good path,” providing teams with detailed results. These include video replays, logs, and network data, which are instrumental in debugging and refining the app’s quality.
Enhanced Collaboration
Waldo’s collaborative tools enable sharing and annotating test session replays, fostering a unified understanding of test outcomes. The tool’s efficacy is echoed in customer testimonials from leading mobile apps, emphasizing its role in promoting efficient app development.
Broad Framework and CI Tool Compatibility
Supporting a wide array of mobile development frameworks and CI tools, Waldo stands out as a versatile option for app test automation services. It includes compatibility with Objective-C, Swift, React Native, and more, alongside seamless integration with CI tools such as Circle CI and GitHub Actions.
Accessibility and Team Collaboration
The platform’s accessibility extends to all organization members, not just the technical staff, making it an inclusive tool for automated test suite maintenance. This promotes transparency and collective problem-solving within teams.
Getting Started
Waldo invites potential users to experience its features through a free trial or a personalized demo, showcasing how it can streamline their mobile app automation testing process.
Customer Validation
Positive reviews from various industry players highlight Waldo’s ease of use and its capability to conduct tests at scale, adding significant value to mobile app development workflows.
Key Takeaways
- Waldo offers a user-friendly platform for automation testing mobile apps.
- The tool provides comprehensive testing artifacts for thorough issue resolution.
- It supports a multitude of frameworks and CI tools, enhancing its adaptability.
- Waldo’s design promotes team collaboration and is accessible for all skill levels.
Waldo stands as a notable contender in the mobile test automation tools comparison, simplifying the testing landscape for mobile app development teams.
Pros and cons of Waldo
Pros
- Tests from a real user’s perspective, making it less sensitive to UI changes.
- Finds elements even if they change position, ID, or size, leading to more successful test completions.
- Assertion feature alerts when changes are detected that may need review.
- Includes a flakiness score to identify and improve flaky tests.
- Advanced features like deep linking and branch testing enhance testing capabilities.
- Contributes to faster and more efficient development cycles by catching bugs earlier.
- Allows for confidence in releasing new updates without full manual regression.
- Scalable and reliable technology that mimics real user interactions.
- Excellent customer support with proactive outreach and dedicated communication channels.
- Reduces manual testing time significantly, allowing for faster feedback loops and quicker bug fixes.
Cons
- Continuous evolution of the product can require frequent adaptation of testing methods.
- Some users experience slower execution speed of test suites.
- Edge cases may be challenging to automate with the current toolset.
- No-code approach may lead to updating tests only after new code breaks them.
- Learning curve associated with adopting new developer tools like Waldo.
- Can’t automate 100% of tests, as certain scenarios may still require manual attention.
- End-to-end tests, particularly on mobile, can be inherently slow.
- Dependency on the tool’s updates and improvements for better performance.
- Some initial setup and familiarization with the technology are necessary.
- May not be as intuitive for teams accustomed to traditional code-first testing approaches.
Bitbar by Smartbear
SmartBear’s BitBar is a cloud-based platform for web and mobile app test automation services, offering a seamless experience for developers and QA teams. It streamlines the automation testing of mobile apps by providing a diverse selection of real browsers and devices, eliminating the need for in-house lab upkeep.
Simplified Testing with BitBar
- Browser Testing: Test web applications across various browsers to ensure consistent functionality.
- Device Testing: Access a vast array of real mobile devices for thorough app testing.
- Enterprise Solutions: Public and private cloud deployments meet diverse security and infrastructure needs.
Enhancing Test Automation
- Accelerated Test Cycles: Run tests in parallel to expedite cycles and improve coverage.
- Authentic Test Environments: Use current and upcoming real browsers and devices for accurate testing.
- Maintenance-Free: Focus on testing while BitBar manages the environment setup and maintenance.
- Framework Compatibility: Supports multiple testing frameworks and languages, ready for evolving testing strategies.
- Security Conscious: Secure testing options with public and private clouds, including device cleanup and dedicated devices.
Deployment Flexibility
- Public Cloud: Immediate access to a broad device and browser pool with powerful API integration.
- Private Cloud: Tailored hardware and support for specialized requirements, with enterprise-grade security.
Frameworks and Languages
BitBar is compatible with a variety of testing frameworks and programming languages, ensuring a versatile testing process that adapts to different methodologies.
Start Testing with BitBar
Experience BitBar’s capabilities with a 14-day trial, offering comprehensive tools for both web and mobile app automation testing, without the need for a credit card.
SmartBear’s Comprehensive Tools
BitBar is part of SmartBear’s extensive product ecosystem, which provides an array of tools for software development and quality assurance.
Support and Resources
SmartBear extends its support with educational resources, a community forum, and customer service accessible across multiple regions, ready to assist with your mobile test automation tools comparison and implementation needs.
Pros and cons of Bitbar
Pros
- Extensive support for cross-browser testing, allowing for quick identification of bugs.
- Ability to take screenshots and record tests when a test case fails, enhancing the debugging process.
- Offers a Record & Play feature which is highly valued by users.
- User-friendly interface that supports a large number of browsers, making it easy to test across different environments.
- Positive feedback on the tool’s reliability with no significant dislikes reported by some users.
- Simplifies site updates and cross-browser compatibility checks for multiple clients.
- Provides a wide range of systems and devices for testing purposes.
- Enables efficient automation of testing across various devices and operating systems.
- Cost-effective, with the tool’s efficiency offsetting the expense through time savings.
- Effective dashboard that provides a quick and concise overview of testing status and results.
Cons
- Occasionally, web applications fail to launch on Internet Explorer (IE 11), indicating compatibility issues.
- Customer support experiences have been inconsistent, with some users finding it difficult to get clear answers and technical assistance.
- Aggressive sales tactics have been reported, leading to a negative experience for some customers.
- Pricing discrepancies and lack of clear communication regarding costs have been a concern, resulting in customer dissatisfaction.
- The user experience (UX) could be improved, especially for beginners; suggestions include having different modes for novice and expert users.
- The onboarding process, while praised for being quick and easy, could potentially be further optimized for new users.
Perfecto by Perforce
Perfecto stands out in the realm of mobile test automation tools, providing a robust solution for enterprises aiming to enhance the quality of their mobile applications. It is a platform that supports continuous, automated, and mobile app automation testing, addressing a broad spectrum of testing requirements including web, API, and UX testing.
Streamlined Testing with Perfecto Mobile and Perfecto Web
The platform offers tailored solutions such as Perfecto Mobile and Perfecto Web to facilitate testing across a multitude of devices, browsers, and operating systems, ensuring applications deliver a consistent user experience.
Enhancing Efficiency with Smart Testing Capabilities
Perfecto’s cloud-based test lab allows for efficient test creation, execution, and insightful analytics. Key features include codeless automation for a smooth transition from manual testing, real user simulation for testing under realistic conditions, remote device access for comprehensive testing from any location, and AI-driven analytics for intelligent failure categorization and remediation guidance.
Tailored Solutions for Diverse Testing Scenarios
With a focus on mobile application testing, Perfecto supports continuous and automated testing to identify issues early in the development cycle and optimize testing workflows.
Comprehensive Resources and Support
Perfecto’s commitment to user success is evident through its extensive resources such as educational content, product demos, a regularly updated blog, and customer success stories. The platform also offers professional services, online training, and a broad spectrum of supported devices and browsers.
Flexible Pricing and Hands-on Experience
Different subscription plans and enterprise licenses are available to accommodate various organizational needs, alongside the opportunity to request a free trial to explore the platform’s full potential.
Seamless Integration for Modern Development Workflows
Perfecto’s compatibility with leading automation frameworks like Selenium, Appium, Espresso, and XCUITest, ensures it can be effortlessly integrated into existing development workflows, aiding teams in maintaining a high standard of quality for their mobile and web applications.
For organizations seeking to streamline their mobile app automation testing, Perfecto presents a comprehensive suite of tools and services that support a proactive testing strategy.
Pros and cons of Perfecto
Pros
- Integration with Automation Frameworks: Perfecto seamlessly integrates with leading test automation frameworks such as Selenium and Appium, enhancing the efficiency of scripting and execution of automated tests.
- Device Availability: Offers a comprehensive array of real and virtual devices, enabling teams to test their applications on a variety of devices and operating systems.
- Ease of Use: The dashboard is user-friendly, clean, and straightforward, making it easier for teams to navigate and control required device functionalities.
- Remote Accessibility: Enables distributed teams to access and share devices for testing purposes, regardless of their geographical location, solving the problem of device sharing among teams in different regions.
- Real Device Testing: Provides access to real devices, which is crucial for realistic testing scenarios such as opening a camera or toggling Wi-Fi settings.
- Support for macOS Devices: In addition to mobile devices, Perfecto offers macOS devices for testing, reducing the need for physical devices.
- Efficiency in Execution: Perfecto has shown to significantly reduce the effort required during test execution, with reports of saving up to 95% of effort in regression testing suites.
- Versatility: The tool is versatile and has been successfully employed for testing various types of applications in real-world scenarios.
Cons
- Cost Concerns: The cloud-based testing service can be costly, which might be a barrier for smaller teams or projects with limited budgets.
- Learning Curve: New users may face a learning curve when transitioning from other tools or methodologies to Perfecto.
- Regular Expressions Complexity: Users have found the regular expressions used for device selection to be confusing and unclear.
- Device Update Frequency: There is feedback suggesting that the range of leading devices should be updated more frequently to keep up with the latest models.
- Availability Issues: Occasionally, there are issues with device availability, where specific devices or versions are not accessible or encounter errors after updates or restarts.
- Lack of Negative Feedback: Currently, there is a scarcity of specific negative feedback, which could be due to users not encountering significant issues or the platform not being extensively reviewed in certain aspects.
Appium
Appium is a prominent open-source framework used in mobile test automation tools, enabling cross-platform testing capabilities for native, hybrid, and mobile web applications, as well as desktop apps. It leverages the WebDriver protocol to provide a standardized testing environment across iOS, Android, macOS, and Windows platforms.
Key Features of Appium
- Cross-Platform Testing: Appium facilitates automation testing mobile apps on various platforms without requiring modification or recompilation of the application.
- Language Support: It supports writing tests in multiple programming languages such as Java, Python, Ruby, and C#, offering versatility for different user preferences.
- Ecosystem and Extensions: The framework is surrounded by a robust ecosystem that includes drivers for platform-specific automation, client libraries for programming languages, and plugins to enhance server functionalities.
Migration to Appium 2
Appium has transitioned to version 2, ceasing support for version 1. This shift has introduced a standalone Appium 2 server and the Appium Inspector for efficient test creation and management. Users are encouraged to migrate using the provided Migration Guide.
Installation and Configuration
Appium installation is straightforward via the npm package manager. Post-installation, additional drivers for each platform are managed through Appium’s Extension CLI, streamlining the setup process for mobile app automation testing.
Advantages for Developers and Testers
Appium’s alignment with the WebDriver protocol ensures a consistent and open standard for mobile app test automation tools. Its flexibility, support for multiple languages, and ability to integrate with cloud platforms make it a practical choice for automating mobile application tests.
Appium’s commitment to open standards and its extensive support for diverse platforms, languages, and plugins position it as a comprehensive tool for mobile test automation tools comparison and selection. It remains accessible and free under the Apache-2.0 license, with extensive documentation available for users to optimize their mobile test automation strategies.
Github stats:
- Forks: 5946
- Stars: 17380
- Commits: 10526
- Last commit on: 2024-01-05T10:27:17Z
Applitools
Applitools introduces an advanced AI-powered test automation platform, streamlining the process of mobile app automation testing. This platform leverages Visual AI to refine test creation, execution, and analysis, making it a significant player among mobile test automation tools.
Optimized Testing with Visual AI
Visual AI is at the heart of Applitools, setting it apart in the landscape of mobile application test automation tools. It meticulously validates every UI element, ensuring comprehensive test coverage that spans text, images, layouts, and videos. This capability is crucial for maintaining the visual and functional integrity of mobile apps across various devices and screen sizes.
Comprehensive Test Automation Services
With Applitools’ suite of services, including the Ultrafast Test Cloud and Execution Cloud, teams can execute resilient automation testing for mobile apps. The platform’s no-code solution, Preflight, and the Visual AI validation engine, Eyes, facilitate large-scale UI testing, making it a robust choice for app test automation tools.
Streamlined Integration and Maintenance
Applitools excels in simplifying test maintenance through its auto-maintenance features and SDKs that support integration with popular frameworks like Selenium and Appium. This integration ensures a smooth workflow for development and QA teams, enhancing existing test automation tools for mobile apps.
Elevated Efficiency and Test Coverage
Teams utilizing Applitools benefit from increased efficiency in test creation and maintenance. The platform’s Visual AI technology fosters exhaustive test coverage, reducing the likelihood of bugs reaching production. Moreover, the inclusion of visual accessibility testing tools ensures that applications adhere to visual compliance standards.
Supporting Diverse Teams and Use Cases
Applitools is tailored to meet the diverse needs of development teams, QA professionals, and digital leadership. It supports a wide range of use cases, from functional and visual testing to accessibility compliance, positioning itself as a comprehensive solution in the mobile test automation tools comparison landscape.
By integrating with existing test suites and CI/CD processes, Applitools enhances the efficiency and reliability of mobile app test automation, catering to the ever-evolving demands of software development and quality assurance.
Pros and cons of Applitools
Pros
- Easy to use and implement into existing automation workflows.
- Customer-focused support and assistance.
- Facilitates the detection of unintended changes, especially in large applications.
- Shallow learning curve, making it accessible for QA teams with less coding experience.
- Enhances cross-browser and cross-device testing capabilities.
- Visual regression testing moves beyond simple visibility checks to ensure visual perfection.
- Integration with popular frameworks like Cypress for immediate feedback on changes.
- Offers multiple SDKs for ease of creating and comparing visual snapshots.
- Features like self-healing capabilities for cloud runners improve user experience.
- Supports visual validation for accessibility and early component validation in the delivery cycle.
Cons
- The platform can be sluggish on slower connections or computers.
- Initial maintenance and setup may require some time to get used to.
- Error reporting can be problematic for automated report generation.
- Snapshot quality issues have been observed, although updates have addressed them.
- Lack of built-in support for Azure DevOps Server on pipelines (though now available and updated).
- Misuse of the tool due to a lack of understanding of its collaborative potential.
- Branch and baseline management can be confusing, especially for non-technical team members.
- The cost of Applitools can be prohibitive, especially for large companies requiring many accounts.
- The GUI, while user-friendly, may oversimplify for advanced users or specific use cases.
- While the tool is mature and comprehensive, its powerful features come with a high price tag.
Marathon by MarathonLabs
Marathon emerges as a robust solution for automation testing mobile apps, compatible with both Android and iOS platforms. Its design caters to performance and stability, vital for mobile app automation testing, and supports integration with custom hardware farms. This adaptability positions Marathon among the mobile test automation tools that accommodate diverse technology stacks.
Optimizing Test Execution
Marathon streamlines test processes with features like:
- Test Batching: Efficient organization through grouped test executions.
- Device Pools: Enhancing throughput by running tests concurrently on multiple devices.
- Test Sharding: Evenly distributed tests maintain balanced device workloads.
- Test Sorting: Strategic test ordering, prioritizing longer tests to reduce total execution time.
- Preventive and Post-factum Retries: Advanced planning and controlled retry mechanisms to address test flakiness.
Designed with customization in mind, Marathon allows users to tailor test executions for their specific app test automation requirements.
Strategic Management of Test Durability and Efficiency
To address the critical aspects of test duration and pass rates, Marathon employs:
- Flakiness and Sorting Strategies: Utilizing statistical data for intelligent test queueing and execution order.
- Retry Quotas: Restricting the number of retries to minimize their influence on test cycles.
Seamless Configuration
Marathon requires a Marathonfile for setup, with straightforward configurations for Android or iOS environments, and a Marathondevices file for iOS to define simulators or macOS instances. Remote connections are facilitated via SSH, and the tool is operable from both macOS and Linux machines.
Execution and System Compatibility
Initiating a test run with Marathon is as simple as executing the marathon command in your project’s root. The tool is compatible with systems equipped with Java Runtime Environment 8 or higher.
Marathon Cloud: Scalable Testing Infrastructure
Marathon Cloud expands the tool’s capabilities, offering app test automation services that scale from startups to large enterprises, achieving comprehensive test coverage in a short time frame.
Open Source Community and Compliance
Contributors can engage with Marathon’s development by adhering to its guidelines. Marathon is GPL 2.0 licensed, ensuring compliance with open-source standards.
Marathon stands out as a mobile test automation tool that not only provides efficiency and stability in test automation but also offers extensive support and scalability for mobile test automation tools comparison and selection.
Features:
- Test Batching: Grouping tests to be executed as a batch for better organization and efficiency.
- Device Pools: Utilizing multiple devices to run tests in parallel, increasing test throughput.
- Test Sharding: Distributing tests across devices to ensure that each device has a proportionate workload.
- Test Sorting: Prioritizing the execution order of tests, typically running longer tests first to minimize overall execution time.
- Preventive Retries: Planning ahead for potential test failures due to flaky tests or environments by scheduling retries in advance.
Github stats:
- Forks: 115
- Stars: 538
- Commits: 1856
- Last commit on: 2023-12-07T11:16:09Z
TestComplete by Smartbear
TestComplete by SmartBear Software was an integrated platform that played a significant role in the landscape of mobile test automation tools. It offered versatile solutions for automation testing mobile apps, encompassing desktop, web, and mobile app automation testing. The tool was known for its AI-powered object recognition engine, which streamlined the creation of both scripted and scriptless tests, making it a resourceful choice among app test automation tools.
While TestComplete’s services were discontinued in 2023, its approach to app test automation set a benchmark in the industry. Its capabilities in enhancing the efficiency of quality assurance for applications set a precedent for future mobile application test automation tools. TestComplete’s discontinuation has left a gap in the market, and our mobile test automation tools comparison aims to identify and evaluate alternative solutions that continue to drive the evolution of test automation tools for mobile apps.
Sauce Labs
Mobile test automation tools are pivotal in streamlining the software development lifecycle, focusing on delivering a user-friendly experience. These tools facilitate testing across diverse devices and environments, ensuring mobile apps meet rigorous quality standards.
Streamlining Development with App Test Automation Services
App test automation services play a crucial role in enhancing app quality and performance. With access to a real device cloud, teams can conduct tests on an extensive range of devices remotely, boosting productivity and debugging capabilities.
Enhancing Early-Stage Testing
Emulators and simulators are indispensable for early-stage app testing, offering a cost-efficient method for automation testing mobile apps, especially when integrated into CI/CD pipelines.
Beta Testing and Distribution Efficiency
Mobile app automation testing is made more efficient with secure beta testing platforms. These services simplify app distribution and incorporate features like real-time video feedback and straightforward in-app bug reporting.
Error Monitoring for Optimized App Performance
For ensuring optimal app performance, error monitoring and reporting tools are essential. They provide in-depth crash analytics and insights into failure root causes, helping to minimize risks.
Leveraging Automation Frameworks
Support for popular mobile test automation frameworks allows teams to seamlessly integrate these tools with their existing workflows, ensuring a swift setup with their chosen test automation tools for mobile apps.
Real-World Impact and ROI
Studies, such as Forrester’s The Total Economic Impact™, highlight the tangible benefits of mobile application test automation tools, including cost reduction, productivity boosts, business growth opportunities, and risk mitigation.
By utilizing mobile test automation tools comparison, developers and QA teams can select the most suitable solutions to meet their specific app testing needs, ultimately leading to the delivery of high-quality mobile applications.
Pros and cons of Sauce Labs
Pros
- Easy to integrate with existing codebases, enhancing the adaptability for teams.
- Offers a high degree of versatility for testing across different browsers, devices, and platforms.
- Provides an intuitive user interface that is frequently updated based on user feedback.
- Regularly introduces new features and improvements to the service.
- Boasts a supportive community for troubleshooting and user assistance.
- Enables effective cross-browser and cross-platform testing without complex setups.
- Supports the latest web browsers and mobile operating systems for both forward and backward compatibility testing.
- Facilitates parallel execution, allowing numerous instances to run simultaneously, which significantly reduces test suite execution time.
- Features video recordings of tests to help identify where failures occur.
- Includes a platform configurator to assist in running test suites on real mobile applications.
Cons
- The cost can be high due to the reliance on virtual machines.
- Users may occasionally encounter server errors.
- Customer support response times can be slow.
- Frequent changes in account managers can disrupt service continuity.
- Lacks an option to export test reports in formats such as TestNG, Cucumber, and Extent directly from Sauce Labs.
- The process of copying usernames and passwords from the profile can be cumbersome.
- Errors during testing can occur, requiring users to rely on video features for debugging.
- Does not provide email triage for report notifications of test suites.
- Running real mobile device tests with the same web browser suite can present challenges.
- The time taken for script execution can be a concern for some users.
Accelq
ACCELQ delivers an AI-powered test automation platform that streamlines quality assurance across various applications and industries. Its codeless environment allows for the design and execution of automated tests, making mobile app automation testing more accessible and efficient.
Simplified Test Automation with AI
Leveraging artificial intelligence, ACCELQ enables functional testers to automate without coding, enhancing test cycles and fostering an inclusive environment for team members with diverse technical backgrounds.
Comprehensive Testing Across Platforms
The unified platform extends its capabilities beyond mobile test automation tools, encompassing Web, API, Desktop, and Backend systems, which facilitates a seamless test automation experience for enterprise applications.
Focus on Business-Centric Testing
ACCELQ’s approach to end-to-end business assurance integrates automated testing throughout the entire technology stack, mirroring real user interactions and ensuring that business processes are thoroughly validated.
Accelerated Quality Delivery with ACCELQ LIVE
Addressing the dynamic nature of cloud and packaged applications, ACCELQ LIVE aligns test automation with continuous application updates, contributing to a tangible return on investment through reduced maintenance efforts.
Collaborative Ecosystem
The platform promotes collaboration among QA professionals, from manual testers to IT leaders, and integrates with industry-standard tools like Jira, enhancing productivity and strategic decision-making.
Educational Resources and Community
ACCELQ supports skill development in agile testing with its Q Academy, while fostering community engagement through blogs and events, sharing valuable insights from the automation of over 1.1 million business processes.
Diverse Product Suite and Industry-Specific Solutions
ACCELQ’s product offerings cater to a wide range of needs, including mobile app test automation tools and specialized Salesforce automation solutions, serving industries like finance, healthcare, and retail.
For those interested in embracing an automation-first strategy with a focus on quality lifecycle management, ACCELQ provides a comprehensive platform that integrates mobile test automation tools comparison, app test automation services, and industry solutions. Contact the ACCELQ sales team to explore the platform’s potential for your organization’s test automation needs.
Pros and cons of Accelq
Pros
- Efficiency and Speed: ACCELQ offers a streamlined testing process that enhances overall efficiency and speed.
- Self-Healing Capabilities: The tool has self-healing features that help maintain test accuracy over time.
- Improved Test Coverage: Users report that ACCELQ helps in achieving more comprehensive test coverage.
- Object Repository: A centralized object repository aids in better test management and reusability.
- Defined Framework: ACCELQ comes with a predefined framework that reduces setup time and effort.
- Logging Features: Detailed logging capabilities are available for better tracking and debugging of tests.
- Defined Methods: The tool provides predefined methods that can be used to streamline test creation.
- Salesforce Automation: It is particularly strong in automating tests for Salesforce applications.
- Easy Maintenance: Maintenance of tests is easier due to the tool’s design and features.
- Accelerated Development: Advanced AI capabilities in ACCELQ support faster development of test cases.
Cons
- Java Integration: The need for an in-built editor for Java integrations to custom methods is an area for improvement.
- Desktop UI Issues: Some users encounter issues with the Desktop UI, although alternatives like CLI are available.
- Grid Filters: There is a need for enhancements in Grid Filters to support custom and diverse filter items.
- Data Warehouse Integration: For those dealing with heterogeneous data sources, there may be challenges without a centralized data warehouse.
- ETL Testing Limitations: While ACCELQ simplifies ETL testing, there may be complexities when dealing with varied data transformations and compliance standards.
- Learning Curve: New users might experience a learning curve due to the advanced features and AI capabilities.
- Cost: The pricing model may be a consideration for smaller teams or individual users.
- Limited Language Support: Users who prefer programming languages other than Java may find limited support.
- Customization Limits: Some users may require more customization options than what is currently available.
- Documentation and Support: While not always the case, some users might seek more comprehensive documentation and support for complex scenarios.
Conclusion
In the diverse landscape of test automation tools, we have explored a range of products, each with its unique strengths and potential drawbacks.
Repeato stands out with its user-friendly design and no-code approach, making mobile test automation accessible to both technical and non-technical users. Its free plan, visual element recognition, and support for cross-platform testing are significant advantages. However, iOS testing limitations and restricted CI/CD access on lower-tier plans are points to consider. Learn more about overcoming mobile testing challenges and streamlining your testing processes with Repeato in our articles on running Android over WiFi and removing debug banners in Flutter.
ACCELQ and Applitools offer AI-driven capabilities, with ACCELQ focusing on codeless test creation and Applitools on visual AI. Both tools have a learning curve and can be costly, but they excel in efficiency and comprehensive test coverage.
Mobot leverages robots for real device testing, which can be fascinating but comes with a higher price point and no free plan. Meanwhile, Appium and Detox are open-source alternatives for those seeking cost-effective solutions with strong community support.
Ranorex Studio provides detailed UI testing and cross-platform support but is limited to Windows and priced higher. Bitbar and Sofy offer cloud-based solutions with extensive device and browser support, though Sofy’s minute-based pricing may not suit all projects.
For teams looking for open-source frameworks, Marathon offers features like test batching and device pools but requires familiarity with its configuration files.
Lastly, Waldo simplifies test creation without coding, yet may not cover all edge cases and requires adaptation to its evolving platform.
In conclusion, when selecting a test automation tool, consider factors like pricing, ease of use, platform support, and the specific needs of your project. Explore our other insightful articles on test automation, such as test debt and low-code test automation, to further inform your choice and enhance your testing strategy.
FAQ
Which automation tool is used for mobile testing?
Repeato is a robust app test automation solution for mobile apps that allows for record and replay of user interactions, supporting both iOS and Android platforms. Other popular tools include Appium, Espresso for Android, and XCTest for iOS.
Can mobile testing be automated?
Yes, mobile testing can be automated using tools like Repeato, which offers a no-code setup and the ability to quickly record and replay tests, as well as other tools like Appium and Espresso.
Which tool is best for mobile performance testing?
For mobile performance testing, tools like JMeter, Gatling, and LoadRunner are often used. Repeato can also contribute to performance testing by automating user interaction tests.
Is Appium a mobile test automation?
Yes, Appium is an open-source mobile test automation framework that allows for the automation of native, mobile web, and hybrid applications on iOS and Android platforms.
Which tool is best for mobile automation testing?
Repeato is one of the best tools for mobile automation testing, especially for its ease of use, no-code setup, and support for various frameworks. Appium and Espresso are also widely used in the industry.
How do you automate an app test?
To automate an app test, you can use Repeato to record user interactions with an app and replay them for automated testing. This process doesn’t require coding and can be set up quickly.
What tool is used for automation testing?
Various tools are used for automation testing, including Selenium for web applications, Repeato for mobile applications, and Jenkins for continuous integration/continuous deployment (CI/CD) processes.
Can mobile app testing be automated?
Yes, mobile app testing can be fully automated with tools like Repeato, which supports recording and replaying of user interactions for both iOS and Android apps.
What are test automation services?
Test automation services are third-party offerings that provide expertise, tools, and infrastructure to automate the testing process for software applications, helping teams improve efficiency and test coverage.
What is app automation testing?
App automation testing refers to the process of using automated tools to execute predefined actions on a mobile app, verifying that it functions as expected without manual intervention.
What is application testing services?
Application testing services involve professional services that specialize in testing software applications to ensure they meet quality, functionality, security, and performance standards.
Which software is best for automation testing?
The best software for automation testing depends on the specific needs of the project. Repeato is highly recommended for mobile app testing due to its user-friendly interface, no-code setup, and compatibility with various frameworks.